Abdulla Shahid. (Sun Photo/Moosa Nadheem)
The defense for former Foreign Minister Abdulla Shahid argued before the High Court that he has no stepchildren and that his detention was unlawful, claiming it was based on an accusation not included in the original remand submission form—specifically, the charge of sexually abusing a stepchild while in a position of trust.
The High Court concluded its hearing on Shahid's detention on Sunday. The ruling in the case, which was conducted behind closed doors, has now been published on the High Court's website.
Despite the defense’s argument that Shahid does not have a stepchild, the High Court rejected the plea and upheld the Criminal Court's decision to remand him for 30 days.
Shahid was arrested on November 2 on suspicion of sexually abusing a minor. Following an appeal by Shahid against the Criminal Court's 30-day remand order issued on November 3, a three-judge bench of the High Court unanimously ruled on Sunday that there were no grounds to overturn the order.
Defense Points:
Shahid's defense raised three primary points before the High Court, seeking an order for his immediate release.
Absence of a stepchild and detention on unstated charges: The defense argued that although the Prosecutor General's remand request form accused Shahid under Section 9 of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act (abuse of a stepchild), he has no stepchildren. It contended that detaining him based on evidence relating to a charge not specified in the form was procedurally flawed.
Validity of evidence: The defense stated that the evidence considered sufficient to justify his detention consisted of hearsay, which it argued is not legally admissible.
Absence of the victim's statement: Citing the Supreme Court's Ahmed Mukhtar case, which establishes the child's statement as the primary basis in such matters, the defense argued that since investigators had not yet obtained a statement or conducted an interview with the child, the suspect should not be held in custody.
State's Response:
The State clarified that the form identified Shahid as the child's stepfather because statements obtained during the investigation indicated that the child addressed him as "Bappi" (Dad), suggesting that the child perceived him as a stepfather. The State further argued that the remand stage is not intended to establish guilt but is an early phase of an investigation, for which sufficient evidence exists to justify detention.
High Court Decision:
In an opinion authored by Judge Ismail Shafeeu and supported by Chief Judge Abdulla Jameel Moosa and Judge Fathimath Farheeza, the court ruled that although the child's stepchild status was disputed, prima facie evidence supported the relationship as described by the State. The court further noted that the legal caution issued upon Shahid's arrest clearly stated the suspicion of sexual acts with a minor. Therefore, his detention could not be considered one based on an unstated charge.
Standard for Detention:
The court emphasized that detention during the investigative stage does not require proof of guilt but rather "some evidence", as established in the Supreme Court's Mafthooh Saeed case. The lower court's records indicated that this threshold had been met.
Absence of victim's statement:
The court noted that the Supreme Court's Mukhtar case concerns the evaluation of evidence during the trial stage. At the investigative stage, even in the absence of a direct statement from the child, there is no legal barrier to detention based on statements from individuals to whom the child spoke and other corroborating evidence.
Consequently, the High Court found no legal grounds to invalidate the Criminal Court's 30-day remand order and upheld the lower court's ruling.