Mohamed Minhaj.
The Addu Hithadhoo Magistrate Court has issued a ruling declaring Mohamed Minhaj, 29, of Minha, S. Hithadhoo, deceased, four years after he went missing when a speedboat travelling from Malé to AA. Ukulhas capsized on October 5, 2022. The ruling outlines the judicial and Shariah-based principles applied in determining the legal status of a person who remains missing for an extended period, providing a framework for families and next of kin in similar circumstances.
The case was filed by Minhaj’s sister, Muzna Moosa Didi, seeking a judicial declaration of his death. In the judgment, Magistrate Rafeeudheen Ahmed detailed the key Shariah and legal principles considered in determining that a missing person is deceased.
Under the Maldivian Constitution and existing laws, where specific legislation does not provide a direct resolution, judges are required to refer to the principles of Islamic Shari'ah. The court report noted that Islamic jurisprudence generally classifies missing persons (Mafqud) into two categories. The first covers circumstances in which death is not highly probable, such as a person disappearing while travelling for trade or education without any subsequent information. The second concerns hazardous circumstances in which death is highly probable, such as disappearing on a battlefield or from a sinking vessel.
The court observed that Minhaj’s case falls under the second category. The ruling stated that in such perilous circumstances, where a person remains missing without further evidence, the maximum waiting period is four Hijri years. In Minhaj’s case, this four-year Hijri period, which concluded on 11 Rabi' al-Awwal 1448 or August 23, 2026, had been fulfilled.
Furthermore, the court highlighted that the speedboat ‘Trans Secura’ capsized near AA. Maalhos on the night of October 5, 2022, amid heavy seas. The judgment noted that the circumstances of the vessel capsizing in the open sea represented a situation in which survival was naturally improbable and the risk of drowning was extremely high.
Magistrate Rafeeudheen Ahmed gave significant weight to the testimony of Ali Ahmed from Lh. Hinnavaru, the boat’s captain, who survived by swimming to AA. Feridhoo. Ali Ahmed testified that they had remained in the water for more than 23 hours, using life jackets and a buoy, during which Minhaj’s physical condition deteriorated rapidly. He reported that Minhaj was exhausted, hungry, and in distress. Ali Ahmed further stated that he lost consciousness at around 22:00 on October 6, 2022, and, upon regaining consciousness the following morning, found that both Minhaj and the buoy he had been holding were gone. The court determined that Minhaj’s physical condition when he was last seen indicated a low probability of survival and a high likelihood of death.
Following the accident, the MNDF Coastguard and Police launched an extensive search operation. The MNDF report confirmed that search and rescue efforts continued for more than 96 hours, covering 2,000 square nautical miles by sea and air. The operation involved the Coastguard Ship Shaheed Ali, Fast Interceptor Craft Hakura, and Dornier aircraft. Despite these efforts, neither Minhaj nor his buoy was found. Taking these circumstances into account, the judge concluded that, although a four-year period had been observed in the hope of his return, the complete absence of information or physical evidence suggesting that he was alive meant there was no longer any judicial or legal basis to presume his survival.
Regarding the disappearance, Chief Superintendent of Police Mohamed Basheer stated at a press briefing on October 15, 2022, that specialized investigation teams had been dispatched to the atoll. However, he noted that certain aspects of the captain's account had raised questions, particularly concerning the location where the vessel capsized and the large quantity of fuel on board.
An absentee funeral prayer (Gha'ib) can only be performed after a court has officially declared a missing person deceased. Following the Addu Hithadhoo Magistrate Court’s ruling, the funeral prayer in absentia for Mohamed Minhaj was performed at King Salman Mosque after today's Friday prayer.